Clinique Cream Shaper Eye Liner Shapes and defines with intense, stay-put colour Clinique Cream Shaper Eye Liner Black Diamond 101 is a creamy-smooth pencil with a hint of glitter that defines the eyes. Non-smudging, water- and transfer-resistant Smudge with fingertips. For a thicker, more dramatic line, use a less sharpened point and the side of pencil. Keep the liner to the top lid for a more lifted, youthful effect If you really, really want to go after your bottom lash line, Stiles recommends using a lighter color there than you're using on the top. Shapes and defines with powerful, long-lasting color. This will still give you definition, but feels softer and more flattering Line the eye just above the lash line on the top lid and just below on the bottom lashes.